Service Center
Payments
Welcome to our Insurance Payment Center. Below you will find contact information for many of the companies we represent. We encourage you to pay directly for ease of use and peace of mind, but if the information you seek is not below or you would like to make payment in one of our offices, please call us or stop in and we’ll be happy to assist you.
Advantage Specialty
American Commerce
Phone: 800-222-2214
Website: American Commerce Payment
American European Group/Rutgers Casualty
Phone: 888-925-7100
Website: American European Group/Rutgers Casualty Payment
American Property Insurance Company
Phone: 848-208-2000
AMTrust
Phone: 877-528-7878
Website: AMTrust Payment
Andover Companies
Phone: 800-225-0770 x400
Website: Andover Companies Payment
Applied Underwriters
Phone: 877-234-4420
Chubb
Phone: 800-682-4822
Website: Chubb Payment
CNA
Phone: 877-276-7507
Website: CNA Payment
Cumberland Mutual
Phone: 888-421-1228
Website: Cumberland Mutual Payment
Encompass
Phone: 866-430-2916
Website: Encompass Payment
Farmers of Salem
Phone: 866-233-6905
Website: Farmers of Salem Payment
Foremost
Auto: 888-888-0080
All Other: 800-532-4221
Website: Foremost Payment
FMI
Phone: 800-336-3642
Website: FMI Payment
Guard
Phone: 800-673-2465
Website: Guard Payment
Hanover
Phone:800-573-1187
Website: Hanover Payment
Harleysville
Phone: 866-665-4992
Website: Harleysville Payment
Harford Mutual
Phone: 855-590-2456
Website: Harford Mutual Payment
Hartford
Phone: 877-896-9320
Website: Hartford Payment
IFA
Phone: 877-567-8940
Website: IFA Payment
Insurance Company of the West (ICW)
Phone: 800-877-1111
Website: ICW Payment
Liberty Mutual
Phone: 800-824-7317
Website: Liberty Mutual Payment
Magna Carta/Paramount/Public Service Mutual
Phone: 888-663-7275
Website: Magna Carta/Paramount/Public Service Mutual Payment
Merchants Mutual
Phone: 800-462-1077
Website: Merchants Mutual Payment
Mercury
Phone: 800-503-3724
Website: Mercury Payment
Metlife Auto & Home
Phone: 800-680-3354
Website: Metlife Payment
NJ Skylands
Phone: 866-279-7688
Website: NJ Skylands Payment
Norfolk & Dedham
Phone: 800-688-1825
Website: Norfolk & Dedham Payment
Ohio Casualty
Personal: 866-223-9928
Commercial: 866-290-2920
Website: Ohio Casualty Payment
One Beacon/Tower
Phone: 877-624-7775
Website: One Beason/Tower Payment
Peerless
Personal: 800-228-7830
Commercial: 866-290-2920
Website: Peerless Payment
Penn National
Phone:800-766-2245
Website: Penn National Payment
Philadelphia Contributionship
Phone: 888-627-1752
Website: Philadelphia Contributionship Payment
Philadelphia Insurance
Phone: 877-438-7459
Website: Philadelphia Insurance Payment
Plymouth Rock
Phone: 877-725-6423
Website: Plymouth Rock Payment
Preferred Mutual
Phone: 888-511-2455
Website: Preferred Mutual Payment
Progressive
Phone: 800-776-4737
Website: Progressive Payment
Safeco
Phone: 888-723-3260
Website: SafeCo Payment
Selective
Phone: 800-974-7400
Website: Selective Payment
Travelers
Phone: 800-842-5075
Website: Travelers Payment
USLI
Phone: 866-632-2003
Website: USLI Payment
Utica First
Phone: 800-456-4556
Website: Utica First payment
Utica National
Phone: 800-598-8422
Website: Utica National Payment